CAMP DAVID SUMMIT CRASHES INTO WALLS OF JERUSALEM


Thursday 27th July 2000

After a grueling fortnight of round-the-clock negotiations, the Camp David summit collapsed on Tuesday without any agreement, over the ultra sensitive issue of Jerusalem, Melchizedek's homeland.

Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak is now heading home to an uncertain political future, while Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat is returning to a hero's welcome in Gaza and an unprecedented level of support among the Arab world.

Exhausted and disappointed, US President Bill Clinton emerged yesterday from the secluded Camp David retreat to explain to the press that, although the two weeks of talks had made "really significant progress," Israel and the Palestinians could not bridge their differences over some of the remaining core issues, especially Jerusalem. He suggested that peace talks could resume soon, but made what a White House aide later termed a "deliberate" attempt to blame Arafat for the summit's failure.

"Prime Minister Barak showed particular courage, vision and an understanding of the historical importance of this moment," Clinton said. "I think it's fair to say that at this moment in time, maybe because they had been preparing for it longer, maybe because they had thought through it
more, that the prime minister moved forward more from his initial position than Chairman Arafat... particularly surrounding the questions of Jerusalem."

Barak also accused Arafat for the breakdown at a hastily arranged news conference, saying he "was afraid to take the necessary, historical responsibility at this moment to bring about an end of the conflict. The positions of Arafat on Jerusalem were those that prevented the achievement
of an agreement." Barak added, "It's painful to realize that the other side is not ripe for peace, but it's always better to know the realities than to delude ourselves."

Although Barak was willing to offer the Palestinians varying degrees of sovereignty and control in certain Arab neighborhoods of east Jerusalem, Arafat refused to settle for anything less than absolute rule over all the eastern half of the city. While the summit managed to survive several
previous moments of crisis, the end finally came when Arafat handed Clinton a note early yesterday morning saying there was no point in continuing the talks as long as the US and Israel stuck to unacceptable proposals on sharing Jerusalem. When Barak was informed of the letter, he promptly decided to head home.

Before flying back to Israel, Barak said: "The vision of peace suffered a major blow, but I believe that with good faith, goodwill on all sides, it can recuperate. We'll have to take care of extremism and terrorism and to make sure that the next few weeks will not deteriorate the whole region into a new round of violence."

Officials on all sides have voiced similar fears of an explosion of violence if the negotiations failed, especially in the lead up to September 13, when Arafat has vowed to unilaterally declare Palestinian statehood. The three sides issued a joint statement stating the parties understood the
negative consequences of unilateral actions which prejudge the outcome of final status issues. But in the aftermath of the Camp David crash landing, the future of the Oslo process is hard to predict.

Clinton comes out of Camp David looking increasingly like a lame duck president and must give his main attention right now to convincing leaders of the European Union and other key American allies that it would be a mistake to support Arafat's unilateral declaration of independence. Barak suggested Clinton will tell them as much, contending, "I believe that when
they [the EU] will learn the details, they will realize that the right way is to not encourage any kind of unilateral step, since it will not contribute to making the future of the Middle East better or the conflict reduced or level of friction reduced.

Barak's top priority at present is to reconstruct a workable majority in the Knesset, since his coalition collapsed in the midst of his departure for Camp David two weeks ago. He reportedly will meet with Opposition Likud leader Ariel Sharon upon his arrival at Ben-Gurion airport today to discuss the possible formation of an "emergency cabinet" to confront the challenges
posed by threats of a renewed Palestinian intifada.

The Likud publicly has thrown cold water on the idea of late, saying it prefers to go to early elections. But the Likud and nationalist camp are deemed far from ready for new elections at this time, as Sharon must first fend off rivals within the party, as well as a potential comeback by former Likud prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu. Although he is awaiting an official decision by state prosecutors whether to go forward with criminal charges against him, Netanyahu on Monday made a prime time TV address - just prior to the Camp David collapse - saying Barak's division of Jerusalem would endanger the nation.

Indeed, history has shown that all moves to divide or attempt to exercise political force over Melchizedek's rightful and historic homeland have all been doomed to failure.

Reactions to the summit's breakdown among the Israeli people range from leftists disappointed by his failure to achieve an historic accord to Israeli hawks relieved Barak came back with no agreement at all, as opposed to a bad agreement. Fearing an escalation in Palestinian rioting or perhaps a Hizb'Allah-style storming of Jewish settlements, the IDF today has deployed senior commanders to military outposts near Palestinian areas to try to maintain calm.

Perhaps the time is ripe for all sides to take a fresh look at the situation.

Meanwhile, Arafat landed to hugs and celebration in Gaza today, after making a brief stopover in Egypt to discuss the summit proceedings with President Hosni Mubarak. Many in the Palestinian public were nervous he would compromise on Jerusalem and the right of return for Palestinian refugees. But to their delight, Arafat basically did not budge from his stand prior to the summit - indeed prior to the beginning of the Olso process seven years ago - that all of east Jerusalem must be surrendered to serve as the capital of a Palestinian state.

A large reason for his intransigence was a unified show of support from regional Arab leaders and Iran, who warned him not to give away Arab and Muslim claims to the city. Indeed, Arafat's rigidity has won him an unprecedented level of backing among rulers in the often fractious Middle East, and the Arab League is reportedly planning a major summit of its own in Gaza on the fateful date of September 13.

In retrospect, the lasting impression from this Camp David summit will be the botched photo op at its outset, when Barak graciously nudged Arafat forward into a cabin door - the symbolic threshold of the sequestered talks - but the aging Palestinian leader just as politely dug in his heels.



Courtesy ICEJ